On an otherwise normal evening in 1964, a woman known as "Miss Witness" received a disturbing telephone call from alleged loan shark Frank Sacco. Here is her account of the call:
That evening, I received a phone call from him to look at my car and that "it" would happen to me if I didn't pay up.
The next day, the woman received another call, this time from her brother-in-law who had been using her car. He told her that a bomb had blown her car to bits.
This is not a scene from a classic mobster movie. This story is, in fact, a true account of a 1960s loan shark case in Yonkers, N.Y. The woman - who remained unidentified in news reports - told just one of the many horrific stories about threats and violence used by infamous loan shark rings throughout the country.
Many of the stories involve physical harm, irrevocable monetary problems and even murder. Luckily, we don't hear of these types of cases anymore. With other financial options opening up over the last several decades, the need for loan sharks has put many of these criminals out of business for good.
Today's first pick is one of these new legitimate players in the loan business. And you don't even have to "pay up" to profit from this fast-growing penny stock…
A Painfully Dismal 2009 Forecast Uncovers a Profitable Opportunity
Millions of people all over the world are facing tough financial times these days. All the pundits have compared this economic downturn to the Great Depression. And yes, there are some similarities.
Economists expect unemployment will reach between 8.5-10% in 2009. The only stock market to post a gain last year was Tunisia - a small North African country. Mega players like the UAE and Iceland were all but wiped off the international investment stage.
Home foreclosures are expected to reach an all-time high this year, which will only add to the unbelievably high rate of homes for sale. Prices are still crashing - currently sitting about 35% below a year earlier.
Credit is nearly frozen. Banks and credit card companies alike are buckling down and leaving very little money free to loan out - even with the drastic actions undertaken in Washington.
We aren't writing this to shock you. But you have to understand how bad it's getting for some families. Bills don't go away when the economy turns sour. And many people will need to turn to short-term lenders to get through these tough times.
The Solution to Millions of Americans' Financial Problems
Many view payday loan shops as corrupt, greedy modern-day loan sharks. That's simply not the case. These payday loan companies are providing a needed service. And as today's current economic situation worsens, payday loan shops are cashing in.
No one likes to hear of families being turned out of their houses because of missed mortgage payments. Cash advance businesses offer a solution to these millions of families. Instead of eviction, one solution for a working family is to take out a short-term seven- or 14-day payday loan. Obviously, this is the last option. But faced with foreclosure, it's becoming a more frequently used solution for many who never thought they'd be in that position.
Families facing foreclosure aren't the only ones running to cash advance stores. Many are taking out payday loans to fund unexpected expenses. With more families living paycheck to paycheck than ever before, even paying for the basics is becoming difficult. Electric, telephone and grocery bills are becoming huge hassles for many.
We found one company that has its hand in many essential services that millions will inevitably look to over the next 12-18 months.
Dollar Financial Corp. (DLLR:NASDAQ) is a key player in payday loans, cash checking, money transfers and even prepaid Visa cards. The company owns or franchises over 1,300 stores in the U.S., Canada, the United Kingdom and Ireland.
Dollar owns brands like Money Mart, The Check Cashing Store and American Payday Loans. While not creatively named, these brands are widely recognized.
With leading market shares in Canada and the U.K. and the second largest share in the U.S., Dollar produces over $600 million in revenue and more than $63 million in profits per year. With a market cap of just over $250 million, you might never find a better deal.
How to Play the Game: Market Position and Cash
Dollar's nearly 30 years of experience has given the company an upper hand on its competition in the ever-changing world of payday loans. Over the past century, federal, state and even local governments have imposed various laws and regulations. The largest concern to many is the out-of-control interest rates in place for these quick loans.
Starting in 1917, limitations on the industry have poured in from every agency and bureau you can think of. It took around 70 years to work itself out, but the industry finally found its footing in the early 1990s. By that time, Dollar was already a top dog.
Market dominance is important in this business. After all, it is still the retail business. In times like these, unsure newcomers will look to the largest of lenders, not the small-time convenience stores.
Besides market dominance, the second most important factor when looking into a payday loan investment is cash. If a company doesn't keep a lot of cash on hand, there's no way it can prosper when a wave of customers is banging on its doors. You can't give out loans if you don't have any money. Dollar has plenty.
With over $200 million in hard cash on hand as of Sept. 30, 2008, the company is in prime position to profit in 2009. Compared with its competition, Dollar is far ahead of the game.

Of course, these numbers don't tell the whole story. There are all kinds of other factors not featured in this chart, like debt and accounts payable and receivable. But it does sum up the main point: It takes cash to successfully run a cash advance operation.
A Better Opportunity Than the Best of 2008
Last March, we recommended a company called First Cash Financial Services (also featured in the "Cash Is King" chart). First Cash is similar to Dollar in that it also offers payday loans and cash checking services. The company also runs pawnshop businesses.
When we recommended First Cash, we were at just the beginning stages of the 2008 sell-off. Foreclosure rates were beginning to make headlines. Precious metals were exploding. And of course, the Bear Stearns collapse was the top story on every news channel.
These reasons, along with many others listed in that issue, brought us to recommend First Cash. In just two months, we closed an 82% gain. The economic situation back then now looks like 1999 compared with today's. The argument for First Cash is even stronger now for Dollar.
Another reason we fell in love with First Cash was its unbelievably low ratios. The company was trading at a P/E of 7.8 and a P/S of just 0.64. Dollar makes these numbers look like those of tech companies at the turn of the century.
With a price-to-earnings of less than 5 and P/S of 0.42, shares of Dollar might as well be free. In an economic situation that will dramatically force higher revenue and earnings for any payday loan store, it's unbelievable how low investors are valuing Dollar's stock.
But there is more to this story - and this timing - than just cheap valuations and hard economic times…
Grabbing a Slice of Other People's Tax Returns
Throughout the long history of payday loans, there has never been a better time to invest than right now. That's because there is a virtually guaranteed flood of business just around the corner. Let me explain…
Along with payday advances, short-term loans and prepaid credit cards, Dollar Financial also offers another critical service that is extremely cyclical - tax refund advances.
A great majority of Americans rely on tax refunds. In good years, they use this money to buy new televisions or fund home improvements. In recession years, they use this money to pay bills. Since we are in one of the worst recessions dating back to the Great Depression, the need for these refunds is astronomical. Dollar is expecting a flood of business, which should create a record quarter for the company.
Over the past 12 months, Dollar set a company best by recording $609 million in revenue and $52.5 million in earnings. The greatest increase came from its tax refund check cashing services in the quarter ending March 31, 2008.
There are two ways for Dollar to cash in on this annual boost in business. The company offers both regular check cashing, which guarantees a quick cashing fee for Dollar, and tax refund advances, which provides the company with an even larger return. The company charges the same for refund advances as for payday advances, but the guarantee of being paid is much greater. A history of pay stubs is great, but a guarantee from the U.S. government is even better.
Of course, Wall Street normally accounts for this cyclical behavior. The company's share price has been relatively flat during third-quarter announcements in past years. This year, we suspect something quite different.
You see, investors have beaten Dollar's stock down. But instead of accounting for a larger amount of business this tax year, these same investors have oversold shares. The company will see this boost in revenue. Yet Wall Street continues to ignore this obvious fact. Once those numbers come out - usually, around the second week of May - we could be in for the ride of our lives.
We couldn't find a better time to buy Dollar Financial than right now. We expect a huge year in this absolutely recession-proof play.
Action to take: Buy shares of Dollar Financial Corp. (DLLR:NASDAQ) up to $11.00.
CXS Breakdown: Dollar Financial Corp. (DLLR:NASDAQ), www.dfg.com In a year when millions more Americans (and Europeans alike) will default on their mortgages and struggle with their bills, payday loan centers will prosper. Dollar Financial Corp. will use this opportunity to show its alpha dog status. Now with tax season fast approaching, the company should soon shatter its own quarterly earnings record. It's time to get in on this cash cow. Top-Line Power: Dollar Financial's long history of growing its revenue is impressive. But the next few quarters should blow these numbers out of the park. Tax time is around the corner, and that's like Christmastime for Dollar investors. Score: 2 of 2 Profit Fortress: There's big competition in the payday loan industry, but Dollar can handle it. With the top spot in the U.K. and second largest market share here in the U.S., the company is as fortified as any short-term loan company can be. Score: 1 of 2 Black Clouds: For some reason, Dollar's shares have collapsed over the past 12 months. After starting 2008 at around $30 per share, its stock fell to a mere $6. We waited for it to find a bottom. It's arrived. Investors are starting to see it as well. Now is the time to get in before shares skyrocket. Score: 2 of 2 Profit Catapults: As we mentioned, tax season is almost here, and Dollar's tax cashing/advance services should provide the company with a record quarter. On top of being both lucrative and timely, these services are practically government guaranteed - after all, Uncle Sam is signing the checks. Score: 2 of 2 Business Shock: Dollar might not be breaking any legs or blowing up any cars, but it certainly does shock some. Even so, individuals and companies have been loaning each other cash all of history. Dollar's approach isn't brand-new, but it does seem to work the best. Score 1 of 2 CXS RATING: 8 out of 10 Financials Market Capitalization: $254 million Recent Price: $10.60 Price/Earnings: 4.95 Price/Sales: 0.42 Price/Book: 1.27 |
How the Worst Year in Automotive History Could Pave the Way For Historic Small-Cap Gains
Now is not the time to be in the car business. As the stock market plunged in October, car sales followed suit. Used cars were hit especially hard, with sales tumbling a massive 20.7% in November alone.
It's not only the used car dealers that are suffering. Every facet of the auto business is feeling the heat. Credit is tight, meaning prospective car buyers will need a better credit score if they want a car loan. On top of this, consumer uncertainty and economic woes are persuading consumers to hang onto their old cars a bit longer than they normally would.
The results have been nothing short of devastating. Used car dealers have seen about half as many customers on showroom floors this year, according to The New York Times. Industry insiders and experts don't expect a miraculous turnaround, either. Ford Motor Co. execs are predicting industrywide December sales numbers to drop by 35% from last year. And they don't expect the first quarter to be a lot better.
December was especially brutal to General Motors as well. GM posted a 2008 U.S. sales drop the likes of which has not been seen in 49 years, dragged down by a 31% drop in December. With 2008's numbers now officially in the books, GM's total sales of 2.95 million cars was the least the company has posted since 1959, according to Automotive News.
The industry is, indeed, in turmoil. But there's one company in the auto biz that's prepared to weather the storm. And when business as usual finally returns, this industry leader will emerge stronger and more profitable than ever before.
So are we crazy to bet on a car dealer in the midst of this painful downturn? Read on and decide for yourself…
Buying the Business No One Else Wants
CarMax Inc. (KMX:NYSE) is a name we're almost certain you'll recognize. It's a Fortune 500 company - and one of Fortune's "100 Best Companies to Work For." Most importantly, CarMax is the largest retailer of used cars in the United States.
Obviously, the entire business has been hit hard by recent events: retail, auto and credit markets are three of the most (if not the most) damaged sectors right now. But if you look past the carnage, you'll see that CarMax is prepared to take its business to the next level while others continue to slog through the industry's most difficult economy in decades.
CarMax is not your father's used car lot. The company sets itself apart from the competition with its unique business model that includes no-haggle pricing, strict quality controls and trade-in guarantees. It'll even give you a written promise to buy your old car even if you decide to not purchase a new one.
Staying Smart During the Downturn
Like other car dealers, CarMax has seen a considerable decrease in store traffic. To combat lower sales, the company has taken action early and often to defend its margins and get though the recession in one piece. In reaction to lower store traffic, management has made efforts to reduce inventory year over year by $340 million, and has even improved turnover, and subsequently decreased costs.
Management has also made the decision to temporarily suspend store growth until conditions improve. Growth was originally reduced to five-10 new store openings earlier in 2008. In the third quarter, CarMax opened just one store, in the Charlotte, N.C., market. Looking ahead to 2009, the company will finish construction in progress on four new locations, but will open only one of these for the time being.
Staying smart has been the name of the game - and company management says it intends to stick to the business model that made CarMax the leader in used car sales. Even though industrywide sales are down 30-40%, CarMax will not be dropping prices or offering any gimmicks or discounts. Company policy is everyday low prices, and it will not move away from this model - the consensus is that any type of sale or offer would not improve traffic in these economic conditions.
We happen to agree with this stance. The company was built - and will continue to grow - under this model. We believe offering a no-haggle shopping environment attracts buyers that would normally be wary of used car shopping.
Superior Financing Will Help CarMax Survive and Thrive
In today's economic climate, exposure to subprime debt has been a death knell for scores of lenders. And while at first glance you wouldn't expect a car dealership like CarMax to be affected by financing woes, it certainly has been. That's because CarMax has its own lending arm - CarMax Auto Finance (CAF) - that has dealt the company some unwelcome losses this year. Ultimately, CarMax's unique brand of financing should shield the company from troubles down the road.
At most dealerships, selling a car involves two commissions: one for the employee who sells the car and another for the financing team when they originate a loan. CarMax's system is a little different - at CarMax, customers deal with one salesperson throughout the entire process, financing and all, and the sales team doesn't get any incentives for pushing one loan over another. When a car buyer sits down to look over his financing options, he's presented with side-by-side offers so that he can pick the option that works best. That's a novel idea in the auto finance world…
CarMax customers aren't bound to loans offered by CAF - the company uses financing from third-party lenders as well. If you're wondering why CarMax would provide so much transparency to customers (at the risk of losing out on financing a car it sells), the bottom line is this: CarMax is in the business of selling cars.
While CAF has been a profitable enterprise most years, the dealer's financing arm really serves just as a means to get more cars out the door. As a result, the company isn't interested in holding onto the loans it writes; it packages groups of loans into securities and sells them on the debt market each month.
The practice of unloading most loans right away did a good job of protecting CAF from the horrendous potential losses the unit would have incurred had it been holding onto the debt. That said, a lack of liquidity in the market for securitized debt and a lower volume of cars to finance have been the primary drivers of CAF's losses this year.
When liquidity returns to the securitized debt markets that CAF uses, expect the unit to spin those losses into future profits. All told, with plenty of capital to fund its operations in the interim, the credit crunch should take less of a toll on CarMax than on most other lenders.
Scary Numbers Are Combated With Increased Market Share
When CarMax released third-quarter finances in late December, the results were far from pretty. Store traffic was down considerably, used car sales were down 17% and the company reported a 10 cent per share loss. Selling and administrative expenses also increased to 14.9%, squeezing margins even tighter.
But this recession is giving CarMax the opportunity to scoop up market share as smaller independent dealers bite the dust. Recent data indicate that CarMax continues to gain market share in the late-model used car market. And internal customer surveys indicate customer satisfaction rates are at all-time highs across the board.
As we move into what is set to be a very difficult year for the economy, we believe the outlook for CarMax will improve significantly as 2009 winds down as investors begin to see the light at the end of the tunnel.
Preparing for a Massive Comeback
In a recession like this one, consumers put off the purchase of big-ticket items like appliances, furniture and, of course, cars. CarMax is in no way immune to consumer tendencies, and we should expect the company to continue to post negative sales growth from its existing locations in 2009. However, we do not expect this trend to continue for more than four quarters. As consumer confidence returns, we can expect CarMax to return to an annual growth rate that's well in the double digits.
Remember, CarMax's problems are not internal. Rather, they are a symptom of a lagging economy. CarMax's business model itself is nearly flawless. The company has proven this with its impressive track record of year-over-year growth. CarMax will continue to grow its business - and its share price - once the economy improves.
For this play, time is on our side. Right now, CarMax shares trade about $8 per share. We believe we can get a better price during the early part of this year.
Action to take: Buy shares of CarMax Inc. (KMX:NYSE) if the stock dips to $7.40 per share or less.

CXS Breakdown: CarMax Inc. (KMX:NYSE), www.carmax.com CarMax Inc. (KMX: NYSE) is a dealer of new and used cars that sells vehicles through its 100 car superstores in 41 metropolitan markets. The company focuses on selling late-model vehicles with less than 60,000 miles. To date, CarMax has sold more than 2 million used cars. Top-Line Power: Like most other dealers, CarMax has been hurt recently by a slowdown in car sales. That said, the company is one of the best positioned for a recession. In the long term, CarMax should continue its trend of stellar growth. Score: 1 of 2 Profit Fortress: CarMax's brand recognition is a significant competitive advantage in the used car arena. As cautious consumers opt to purchase pre-owned vehicles, a reputable name like CarMax will be a significant sales factor that other dealers can't measure up to. Score: 2 of 2 Black Clouds: With the economy in recession, cars dealers have been hit harder than ever before as sales have slowed significantly year over year. Locally owned used car dealers are feeling the pinch, and CarMax is ready to step in and fill the void. Score: 1 of 2 Profit Catapults: CarMax's unique customer-centric business model makes the company a standout among dealers. When consumer confidence again favors auto sales, this company will be a first stop for many. Score: 2 of 2 Business Shock: Bringing reputability to the used car market has proved to be a game changer for CarMax, a fact that hasn't lost any of its cachet. Its no-haggle pricing policy attracts a new demographic to the used car market Score: 2 of 2 CXS RATING: 8 out of 10 Financials Market Capitalization: $1.81 billion Recent Price: $8.23 Price/Earnings: 42.14 Price/Sales: 0.24 Price/Book: 1.17 |